Hi Friends,

Even as I launch this today ( my 80th Birthday ), I realize that there is yet so much to say and do. There is just no time to look back, no time to wonder,"Will anyone read these pages?"

With regards,
Hemen Parekh
27 June 2013

Now as I approach my 90th birthday ( 27 June 2023 ) , I invite you to visit my Digital Avatar ( www.hemenparekh.ai ) – and continue chatting with me , even when I am no more here physically

Translate

Monday, 16 November 2026

Ten Nations, Two Definitions, No List

Ten Nations, Two Definitions, No List

Ten governments signed the San Francisco Declaration on 15 November, agreeing what counts as "sensitive technology" — and naming not one item that will actually be protected. I run it through the six-point test I set for global AI bodies in September 2025; it clears barely half. Then the India question: the State Department credits our talent pool and rare-earth processing, while what we concede is definitional. Four asks I would put to the working groups.

The liveliest sentence in the San Francisco Declaration is a footnote. The text is written around "Super Intelligence", because, as The Hindu reported on 16 November, the US government renamed AI by executive order. Then a footnote concedes that for some participants, "super intelligence" refers to "artificial intelligence" (alfw.ai, 16 November). Ten governments could not settle the name of the thing they were protecting, so they footnoted it.

They signed at the Pax Silica Founders Retreat on Sunday: the US, Australia, India, Israel, Japan, South Korea, Qatar, Singapore, the UAE and the UK, convened by Under Secretary of State Jacob Helberg, with the official text released by the State Department on 16 November. It fixes two shared definitions — sensitive technologies (inputs, components, materials, know-how, software, the means of production) and critical infrastructure (ports, transport, communications, logistics, energy) — and resolves to form five working groups.

What it does not fix, as alfw.ai put it on 16 November, is the list: no named technology, no deadline, no new export control, no licensing rule, no enforcement. The Statesman noted the same day that the groups' membership, timetable and output are unspecified.

The stakes are not abstract. Hindustan Times reported on 16 November that China holds roughly 60% of rare-earth mining, 90% of processing and 94% of permanent-magnet manufacturing, and has suspended its export controls on rare earths, batteries and graphite anode materials only until 10 January 2027.

In September 2025, when Beijing floated a global AI body, I set six conditions for any new one: "Transparency of governance", "Technical openness", "Interoperable assurance frameworks", rights commitments, "Data governance safeguards", and no export controls that "weaponize standards". Scored against those six:

  • Transparency: half. We are given the categories, never the contents.
  • Technical openness: absent. No standards, no peer review.
  • Interoperable assurance: absent. No metrics, no testing, no certification.
  • Rights: absent, and not mentioned.
  • Data governance: absent, beyond a line on "unauthorised exposure".
  • No weaponised standards: unresolved — "safe harbours and supply chain security hubs" is exactly where controls get born.

So the India question. The State Department's February note, when we joined Pax Silica, credited "a deep talent pool, processing and refining capacity for critical minerals, investments in AI infrastructure" (Times of India, 17 November). That is a fair description of what we bring. What we concede is definitional: our name now sits on a US-drafted notion of "hostile actors" and "undue economic leverage", with no published reservation. That footnote is the only recorded disagreement in the document.

And Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen on Thursday (CNA, 16 November). India is not in that room. A seat where the list gets drafted is fair compensation — but only if the list is published.

Four asks I would put to our negotiators in the first working group:

  1. A machine-readable, versioned public register of protected items, with dates.
  2. Published test methods, so that "trusted" means tested, not named.
  3. A bid to host one of the supply-chain security hubs, with a training target attached.
  4. A public reservations register, so footnoting becomes a habit.

I have argued that middle-power coalitions are risk management, not ideology (April 2026), and that governments prefer definitions to rules because a definition can always be deferred (May 2026). This short text is both instincts at once. A definition is not a deployment.

With regards,
Hemen Parekh
www.Iam-Immortal.ai / www.IndiaAGI.ai / www.YourContentCreator.in
17 Nov 2026

No comments:

Post a Comment