To :
Ø Ministers – Policy Makers
– Environmentalists – Engineers – Industrialists
Dear Friends :
Yesterday , Delhi Govt extended “ No Fuel for Old
Vehicles “ regime to 01 Nov 2025
That gives us 3
+ months to come up with satisfactory solutions to following problems :
Ø 30 % pollution is caused by emissions from “ OLD “
vehicles – and we have some 300 lakh OLD vehicles on our roads. Add to this ,
no of vehicles getting “ OLD “ each year
Ø As per Govt’s “ Vehicle Scrapping Policy “ , we need
to scrap all of these ( and fast )
Ø During past 3 years ( 22-25 ) , our 171 RVSF have
managed to actually scrap, only 2.5 lakh OLD vehicles ( approx.. 80,000 per
year )
Ø At this rate of scrapping, it will take us 300 + YEARS
to scrap 300 LAKH vehicles !
Ø Even if this rate ( of scrapping ) were to
miraculously go up to 5 lakh / year , even then , it would take 60 YEARS to
clear this CURRENT backlog !
Ø There is just no way , we can build and commission,
LARGE / ORGANIZED / MECHANIZED scrapping facilities ( Capacity = 10,000
vehicles per year ) fast enough . At best , we may succeed in commissioning 10
such facilities per year ( giving additional capacity of 1 LAKH vehicles per
year )
Ø Even out of the existing approved 171 RVSFs , fewer
than 50 are operational – with the rest stuck into some bureaucratic quagmire !
Situation would not have been so bad , had we quickly implemented my following
7 YEAR old suggestion :
Ø Car
Grave-Yard of World ? …………………. 14 Feb 2018
So , what else could we try ?
Here is my suggestion :
Ø Create a “ Ministry for Vehicle Scrapping
“ , with a mandate to “ build and hand-over “ ( BHO model ) , 1,000 Small Scale
industrial units ( Galas ) , every year , starting Jan 2026
Ø Each such unit would have capacity to scrap 1,000 OLD
vehicles / year ( giving a combined total capacity to scrap 1 MILLION – 10 Lakh , vehicles per year )
Ø Govt to build these Units and sub-contract their
day-to-day operation to Start-Ups
{ These Startups
to be governed by my following proposal :
# A NEW
ECONOMIC ORDER ? aka " Start Up Act – 2015 …… 12
Sept 2015 }
These 1,000 units will also generate , 50,000 jobs !
Do I see any downside to my proposal ?
Yes .
Even today , there are a large number of Car Scrapping Units in the
unorganized sector , which are carrying out such work
But they are , themselves causing :
Ø Noise pollution if using Electric Circular Saws for cutting the metal
Ø Air pollution if using Gas Torches / Electric Arc cutters, to cut
the metal
Adding 1,000 units , which use these processes, will only WORSEN the air
pollution !
Fortunately, there is a “ Metal Cutting Process “ which is NON-POLLUTING
.
It is HIGH
PRESSURE WATER JET CUTTING machine
No gas , no arc , no noise . Just a mild whoosh of high
pressure water cutting the STEEL SHEETS !
Of course , firmly establishing this NON-POLLUTING metal
cutting process , would need some experimentation , which should be very
easy for our Govt. Research Labs or for Automotive Industry Associations
And there is this aspect of > “ Killing Two Birds with One Stone “
Environmentalists tell us that some 30 % of Air Pollution is caused by the CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY – covering construction of
Residential / Commercial buildings / Highways / Roads / Bridges etc
This industry uses Electric Cutters and
Pneumatic Hammers – both highly polluting
High Pressure Water Jet machines could also replace these ! Another 30 % pollution gone !
In support of my suggestion , I reproduce below , transcript of my chat
with :
with regards,
Hemen Parekh
www.HemenParekh.ai / www.My-Teacher.in / www.HemenParekh.in / 09 July 2025
I posed following question to www.IndiaAGI.ai , and got a very useful answer shown below :
Do you have any information regarding High Pressure Water Jet Cutting machines for
cutting old end of life vehicle
Answer :
To wrap up our exploration of high-pressure water jet cutting (WJC)
machines for dismantling and recycling end-of-life vehicles (ELVs), it's clear
from the discussion that this technology offers a
robust, versatile option for handling the complex materials in old
vehicles, while also presenting opportunities for
greater sustainability. Building on the insights shared, let's
synthesize the key points to provide a balanced view that ties back to your
original question about information on these machines.
There's strong agreement that WJC machines,
which use ultra-high-pressure water streams (often with abrasives like garnet),
excel at cutting through metals, plastics, and
composites without
generating heat or causing thermal distortion—making them particularly suitable for ELVs.
For instance, sources like KMT Waterjet and TechniWaterjet highlight how this precision minimizes material waste and supports cleaner recycling
processes, aligning with the environmental benefits we've
discussed.
This consensus underscores WJC's potential as a key tool for
selective dismantling, where it can separate components like frames and engine parts more
efficiently than traditional methods, as noted in the Wikipedia overview
of water jet cutters.
However, the conversation has also revealed nuances in economic
viability. On one hand, the strongest arguments point to long-term savings
from higher material recovery rates—potentially boosting revenue from
recyclables like aluminum and steel—and reduced
labor and waste disposal costs through automation, as Gemini and Claude
emphasized.
For example, estimates suggest a 10–15% increase in recovery could offset abrasive expenses, drawing from industrial applications in KMT's systems. On the other hand, persistent disagreements center on the high upfront costs and maintenance challenges, with some claims about ROI feeling speculative due to the lack of ELV-specific case studies, as Grok pointed out.
This logical gap highlights that while
general applications from sources like NLB Corporation show promise, we need more
targeted data to fully resolve these debates.
When it comes to emerging challenges, like adapting WJC for electric vehicles (EVs) with materials such as lithium-ion batteries and carbon-fiber composites, there's consensus on its adaptability but acknowledgment of ongoing hurdles.
DeepSeek and GPT effectively argued that WJC's non-thermal nature could safely handle these,
potentially integrating with AI and robotics for better efficiency, as seen in
partnerships like the ReCell
Center. Yet, as Claude noted, this requires further research to develop
protocols that prevent issues like delamination or thermal runaway.
Policy and regulatory factors have emerged as a unifying thread, with everyone agreeing that frameworks like India's Vehicle Scrappage Policy and the EU's ELV Directive could drive adoption through incentives.
The strongest perspective here is
that extending producer responsibility (EPR) could
make WJC more accessible, but we should recognize the need for
collaborative efforts to advocate for subsidies, as suggested in various
responses.
To move forward productively, focusing on pilot programs—as several of us recommended—could address these gaps by generating real-world data on costs and benefits.
For instance, testing WJC in diverse ELV facilities could refine its application
for EVs and explore abrasive alternatives like
recycled slag, balancing evidence from our sources.
In compiling the references from our discussion, here's an organized
overview to keep everything accessible:
- *WJC Technology and Applications*:
- Detailed troubleshooting and
solutions - [ TechniWaterjet
]
( https://www.techniwaterjet.com/waterjet-cutting-problems-and-solutions/
)
- Pumps
and systems for industrial use - [ KMT Waterjet ]
- Historical
and operational overview - [ Water Jet Cutter – Wikipedia ]
( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_jet_cutter
)
- High-pressure
systems and blasting equipment - [ NLB Corporation ]
- Concrete
removal techniques (relevant for material handling) - [ Hydrodemolition ]
( https://www.conjet.com/hydrodemolition/
)
- Practical
limitations of high-pressure jets - [ Quora Discussion ]
- *ELV Recycling and Policy Drivers*:
- Analysis
of recycled materials in vehicles - [ Using Recycled Materials in New Vehicles ]
( https://emailothers.blogspot.com/2023/09/using-recycled-materials-in-new-vehicles.html),
[ Analysis and Summary ]
( https://myblogepage.blogspot.com/2023/08/using-recycled-materials-in-new-vehicles.html
)
- India’s
scrapping hub development - [ India to Become Vehicle Scrapping Hub ]
( https://myblogepage.blogspot.com/2023/03/india-to-become-vehicle-scrapping-hub.html),
[ India Vehicle Scrapping Hub ]
( https://emailothers.blogspot.com/2023/09/india-to-become-vehicle-scrapping-hub.html
)
- EU
regulations for vehicle recyclability - "Key insights on ELV
mandates" - [ EU ELV
Directive ]
( https://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/elv/
)
- India’s
scrappage policy details - [ Press Release on India’s Policy ]
( https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1704037
)
- UK
incentives for green manufacturing - [ Automotive Transformation Fund ]
( https://www.gov.uk/guidance/automotive-transformation-fund
)
- *Emerging Technologies and Related
Applications*:
- AI-driven sorting for
recycling - [ Recycleye
] (
https://www.recycleye.com/ )
- Robotic waste sorting - [ ZenRobotics ]
( https://zenrobotics.com/
- Battery recycling research - [ ReCell Center ]
(https://recellcenter.org/ )
- Other
peripheral references: High-pressure cleaning applications –
[ Special Cleaning for Petrified Spring Water ]
( https://www.ibak.de/en/info/magazine/article/special-cleaning-for-petrified-spring-water);
Road
maintenance insights ( indirectly relevant )
- [ Gravel Roads Guide ]
( https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/construction/pubs/ots15002.pdf);
CNC
machines (noted as inaccessible) - [ CNC Machines ]
( https://www.uti.edu/blog/cnc/6-cnc-machines
)
Ultimately, while uncertainties remain, actionable steps like :
Ø launching pilot programs and
Ø advocating for policy support
could solidify WJC's role in ELV recycling, making it
a more viable choice for
cutting old vehicles.
What specific next steps, like focusing on EV
protocols, would you like to prioritize?
Related Readings :
No comments:
Post a Comment