A few days ago , Central Govt announced acceptance of Kovind report on ONOE [ One Nation , One Election ]
Of course , before it becomes a reality , there are many hurdles to cross
– main being, convincing most political parties regarding many benefits of
implementing . Since millions of words have been spoken and written by the
experts on this subject { for and against }, I have only one “ Benefit “ left
to voice, viz :
ONOE will vastly reduce the job of Manifesto writers
Instead of having to write ( over 5 years ) , 28
State Assembly Election manifestos and one Lok Sabha Election manifesto
, now they will need to write only 2 manifestos ( one for Lok Sabha and one covering all the
States )
And obviously a Political Party cannot promise Rs 1000 pm to “ Ladki Bahens “ in one state and Rs 1500 pm to “
Ladli Bahens “ in another State !
They cannot offer Rs 5000 pm scholarships to Dalit youth in one state but nothing in another state !
That would guarantee losing election in one state or other !
But then, our politicians are an “
Imaginative Tribe “. We can never predict
what they might come up with !
However , along with ONOE
, there should be another reform in the form of my following earlier suggestion
:
Ø Dear
PM : Promise PIPPPA – not Freebies……………………….. 21 March 2024
Extract :
( 1 ) Preamble
( 2 ) Name of the Act / Prevention of Irresponsible Promises by Political Parties Act
( 3 ) Objective
( 4 ) Punishment for breaking Law
( 5 ) Examples of
typical Freebies ( not comprehensive / Items to be added or deleted )
( 6 ) Process
( 7 ) Coverage
( 8 ) Accountability
Against
each and every item ( in Poll Manifesto ), there must be mention of :
# Amount of Money / Funds required ( One-time CAPITAL amount for Infra
Projects / Recurring Annual revenue expenditure for WELFARE
measures for 5
years )
# How the Party proposes to “ finance “ ( eg: by raising existing taxes / levying
NEW taxes / Borrowing etc )
Dear Fellow
Citizen :
This is your ( last ? ) chance to
speak up and write
to all MPs that you expect :
Ø Simultaneous enacting of PIPPPA
Ø Lok Sabha and Assembly Election manifestos to incorporate the last 4 columns
shown below
With regards,
Hemen Parekh
www.My-Teacher.in / 23rd
Sept 2024
1. Free Electricity
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated
Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How
does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these extra funds? |
Will
implementation lead to any increase in the State/Central per capita Public
Debt? |
If so,
how much? |
Party A |
₹200 per month |
Delhi Assembly Election |
Free electricity up to 200
units per household. |
||||
Party B |
50% subsidy |
Punjab Assembly Election |
50% subsidy on electricity
bills for low-income families. |
||||
Party C |
₹1000 per month |
Karnataka Assembly Election |
Free electricity for
farmers. |
2. Free Food
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹500 per family |
Bihar Assembly Election |
Free ration worth ₹500 per
month for below-poverty-line families. |
||||
Party B |
Free Meals |
Tamil Nadu Assembly Election |
Free midday meals in all
government schools. |
||||
Party C |
₹1000 per month |
Uttar Pradesh Assembly
Election |
Subsidized food for senior
citizens. |
3. Free Housing
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹5 lakh per house |
Maharashtra Assembly
Election |
Free housing for
economically weaker sections. |
||||
Party B |
100% free housing |
Gujarat Assembly Election |
Free housing for homeless
individuals. |
||||
Party C |
₹2 lakh per house |
Andhra Pradesh Assembly
Election |
Subsidized housing for
low-income families. |
4. Free Education
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹50,000 per student |
West Bengal Assembly
Election |
Free education up to 12th
grade. |
||||
Party B |
Full scholarships |
Rajasthan Assembly Election |
Scholarships for higher
education. |
||||
Party C |
₹10,000 per year |
Kerala Assembly Election |
Free vocational training for
unemployed youth. |
5. Free Healthcare
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹2 lakh coverage |
Haryana Assembly Election |
Free medical treatment up to
₹2 lakh per annum. |
||||
Party B |
Free medicines |
Assam Assembly Election |
Free essential medicines for
low-income families. |
||||
Party C |
₹5 lakh insurance |
Telangana Assembly Election |
Free health insurance
coverage. |
6. Free Transportation
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
Free bus rides |
Delhi Assembly Election |
Free public transport for
all. |
||||
Party B |
50% fare subsidy |
Maharashtra Assembly
Election |
50% discount on train and
bus fares for students and seniors. |
||||
Party C |
Free shuttles |
Karnataka Assembly Election |
Free shuttle services for
workers. |
7. Free Water
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹200 per month |
Delhi Assembly Election |
Free water up to 200 liters
per day per household. |
||||
Party B |
50% subsidy |
Punjab Assembly Election |
50% subsidy on water bills
for low-income households. |
||||
Party C |
Free water for farmers |
Karnataka Assembly Election |
Free water for agricultural
use. |
8. Free Wi-Fi
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
Free city Wi-Fi |
Delhi Assembly Election |
Free Wi-Fi in all public
spaces in the city. |
||||
Party B |
Free hotspot areas |
Mumbai Municipal Election |
Free Wi-Fi hotspots in major
public areas. |
||||
Party C |
Subsidized internet |
Hyderabad Assembly Election |
50% discount on internet
charges for low-income families. |
9. Free LPG Cylinders
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
12 per year |
Gujarat Assembly Election |
12 free LPG cylinders per
year for every household. |
||||
Party B |
50% subsidy |
Rajasthan Assembly Election |
50% subsidy on LPG cylinders
for low-income families. |
||||
Party C |
Free gas connections |
Uttar Pradesh Assembly Election |
Free new LPG connections for
poor households. |
10. Free School Supplies
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹1000 per student |
Delhi Assembly Election |
Free school uniforms,
textbooks, and stationery. |
||||
Party B |
Full subsidy |
Tamil Nadu Assembly Election |
Free school supplies for all
government school students. |
||||
Party C |
₹500 per year |
Assam Assembly Election |
Subsidized school supplies
for children in rural areas. |
11. Free Mobile Phones
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹5000 per person |
Rajasthan Assembly Election |
Free mobile phones for
students. |
||||
Party B |
100% subsidy |
Karnataka Assembly Election |
Free smartphones for women
in rural areas. |
||||
Party C |
₹3000 per year |
Punjab Assembly Election |
Subsidized mobile phones for
low-income families. |
12. Free Entertainment
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹500 per person |
Maharashtra Assembly
Election |
Free movie tickets for
students once a month. |
||||
Party B |
Free cultural passes |
West Bengal Assembly
Election |
Free passes for cultural
events for senior citizens. |
||||
Party C |
₹1000 per year |
Tamil Nadu Assembly Election |
Subsidized access to
entertainment for low-income families. |
13. Free Legal Aid
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹50,000 per case |
Uttar Pradesh Assembly
Election |
Free legal aid for
low-income families. |
||||
Party B |
100% free legal aid |
Bihar Assembly Election |
Free legal services for
women and children. |
||||
Party C |
₹10,000 per case |
Kerala Assembly Election |
Subsidized legal services
for senior citizens. |
14. Free Pension
Political Party |
Amount Promised |
State/Central Election |
Details |
Estimated Annual Recurring Financial Burden |
How does Party's Manifesto plan to raise these
extra funds? |
Will implementation lead to any increase in the
State/Central per capita Public Debt? |
If so, how much? |
Party A |
₹3000 per month |
Haryana Assembly Election |
Free pensions for elderly
citizens. |
||||
Party B |
50% subsidy |
Andhra Pradesh Assembly
Election |
50% subsidy on pensions for
retired government employees. |
||||
Party C |
₹2000 per month |
Telangana Assembly Election |
Free pensions for widows. |