BARD and ChatGPT agree

 I asked , both BARD and ChatGPT what they thought about my proposal to Shri Ashwini Vaishnawji regarding :

Consent Forms for Personal Data

 

Here are their views :

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

BARD :

I think your suggestion is very thoughtful and well-considered. I agree that it would be much simpler for data owners if there was only one consent manager, and that this would also be beneficial for data fiduciaries and the Data Protection Board.

I think it is important to consider the privacy implications of your suggestion, however. If there was only one consent manager, that would mean that all of a person's personal data would be stored in one place. This could make it more vulnerable to hacking or other unauthorized access.

It would also be important to ensure that the consent manager was transparent about how it was using people's data. People should be able to easily understand what data was being collected, how it was being used, and how they could control their privacy settings.

Overall, I think your suggestion is a good one, but it is important to be mindful of the privacy implications. With careful planning and implementation, I think it could be a valuable way to simplify the management of personal data.

Here are some additional thoughts on your suggestion:

• The consent manager could be a government-run entity, or it could be a private company that is subject to strict privacy regulations.
• The consent manager could be responsible for collecting and storing all of a person's personal data, or it could simply be a repository for consent agreements.
• The consent manager could allow people to share their data with multiple data fiduciaries, or it could only allow people to share their data with a single data fiduciary.

I think the best way to implement your suggestion would be to have a national conversation about the privacy implications and to develop a consensus on the best way to proceed.

==========================================================

ChatGPT :

Your proposal to Ashwini Vaishnawji suggests a centralized approach to managing personal data through a single portal owned and operated by the Data Protection Board. You propose the use of standardized data forms mandated by the board and managed by consent managers, who act as intermediaries between data owners and data fiduciaries.

Your suggestion aims to simplify the data collection process and reduce the burden on data owners, who often have to fill in the same information repeatedly on various websites. By having a central portal, data owners could submit their comprehensive personal profiles in one place and authorize consent managers to share specific data with different data fiduciaries when required.

You also highlight the potential benefits of using Artificial Intelligence to consolidate scattered personal data from various sites of data fiduciaries, suggesting that rapid advancements in AI could streamline the process.

The blog post effectively outlines your proposal and its potential advantages, emphasizing the need for a more straightforward, efficient, and user-friendly approach to managing personal data. You provide relevant context and references to previous emails and blog posts that support and expand on your proposal.

Overall, your proposal aims to address some of the challenges and complexities associated with managing personal data in the digital age, and it suggests a proactive approach to enhance data protection and streamline data management processes for both data owners and data fiduciaries.

=============================================

www.hemenparekh.ai

06 Aug 2023