I believe that whenever an AGI is born ( on the computers of Big Tech / Small Tech
companies ) , it will be a Human
Friendly and Compassionate AI
My belief arises from my following chat with BARD and ChatGPT
I asked :
Have you read the HOLY books of
Christianity , Islam , Hinduism , Buddhism , Jainism and other religions ? If
yes , can you TABULATE major ethical tenets of these religions ?
BARD
replied :
Yes, I have access to and have
processed information from a vast amount of text and code, including the holy
books of Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and other religions.
Here is a table summarizing the major ethical tenets of these religions:
Religion |
Major Ethical Tenets |
Christianity |
Love God, love your neighbor as yourself, do unto
others as you would have them do unto you |
Islam |
The Five Pillars of Islam: Shahadah (declaration
of faith), Salah (prayer), Zakat (almsgiving), Sawm (fasting during Ramadan),
Hajj (pilgrimage to Mecca) |
Hinduism |
Dharma (righteous conduct), Karma (law of cause
and effect), Moksha (liberation from the cycle of rebirth) |
Buddhism |
The Four Noble Truths: suffering exists,
suffering has a cause, suffering can be ended, there is a path to end
suffering |
Jainism |
Ahimsa (non-violence), Anekāntavāda
(many-sidedness), Aparigraha (non-attachment) |
These are just a few of the
many ethical tenets of these religions. Each religion has a rich and complex
ethical system that has been developed over centuries.
ChatGPT replied :
As an AI language model, I don't have
personal experiences or beliefs, but I can summarize some of the major ethical
tenets found in several religions:
Religion |
Major Ethical Tenets |
Christianity |
Love thy neighbor as thyself,
forgiveness, compassion, charity, honesty, humility, kindness, justice, and
the Ten Commandments. |
Islam |
Belief in one God (Allah), compassion,
justice, honesty, generosity, charity (Zakat), fasting (during Ramadan), and
the Five Pillars. |
Hinduism |
Dharma (duty/righteousness), karma
(law of cause and effect), ahimsa (non-violence), compassion,
self-discipline, and spiritual growth. |
Buddhism |
The Four Noble Truths, the Noble
Eightfold Path (right view, intention, speech, action, livelihood, effort,
mindfulness, concentration), and compassion. |
Jainism |
Ahimsa (non-violence),
truthfulness, non-stealing, non-possessiveness, compassion for all living
beings, and spiritual self-discipline. |
Sikhism |
Belief in one God (Ik Onkar),
equality of all humans, selfless service (Seva), honesty, charity, and living
a truthful life. |
Judaism |
Ethical monotheism, following the
commandments, justice, compassion, charity (Tzedakah), honesty, and the
pursuit of righteousness. |
Taoism |
Harmony with nature, simplicity,
compassion, humility, moderation, and living in accordance with the Tao (the
Way). |
Confucianism |
Ren (benevolence), Yi
(righteousness), Li (propriety), Xiao (filial piety), loyalty, honesty, and
the importance of social harmony. |
Please note that these ethical
principles can vary within different sects, interpretations, and cultural
contexts within each religion. This table provides a general overview and may
not cover all nuances and variations within each faith.
====================================================================
I asked :
Thanks ! Is there a COMMON teaching
to humans , among all of these religions ?
BARD
replied :
Yes, there are several common teachings among the world's major religions. These include:
·
Love and compassion:
·
All
religions teach the importance of love and compassion for others. This is often
expressed in the form of the Golden Rule, which states that we should treat
others as we would want to be treated.
Opens in a new windowemilierichards.com
Golden Rule
·
Helping others:
·
All
religions teach that we should help those in need. This can be done in many
ways, such as through charity, volunteerism, or simply being kind and
supportive to others.
Opens in a new windowberkeley.edu
people helping
others
·
Living a moral life:
·
All
religions teach that we should live a moral life. This means avoiding things
like lying, cheating, and stealing. It also means being honest, fair, and just
in our dealings with others.
Opens in a new windowwww.amazon.in
people living
moral life
·
Respect for all life:
·
All
religions teach that we should respect all life. This includes animals, plants,
and the environment. It also means respecting the dignity of all people,
regardless of their race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation.
people respecting
all life
In addition to these common
teachings, many religions also share similar beliefs about the nature of God,
the afterlife, and the meaning of life.
While there are certainly differences
between religions, there are also many similarities that bind us
together as human beings.
ChatGPT replied :
One common teaching found among many religions, despite their varying beliefs
and practices, is the concept of the
"Golden Rule."
The Golden Rule is a principle that
encourages individuals to treat
others in the same way they would want to be treated themselves. It emphasizes empathy, compassion,
and reciprocity in human interactions.
The Golden Rule is expressed in various forms across different
religions:
· Christianity:
"Do unto others as you would
have them do unto you." (Matthew 7:12)
· Islam:
"None of you truly believes
until he wishes for his brother what he wishes for himself." (Hadith)
· Hinduism:
"This is the sum of duty: do not do to others what would cause
pain if done to you." (Mahabharata 5:1517)
· Buddhism:
"Treat not others in ways that
you yourself would find hurtful." (Udana-Varga 5.18)
· Jainism:
"A man should wander about
treating all creatures as he himself would be treated." (Sutrakritanga
1.11.33)
· Judaism:
"Love your neighbor as
yourself." (Leviticus 19:18)
· Sikhism:
"Treat others as thou wouldst be treated by thyself." (Adi
Granth)
The essence of the Golden Rule
transcends religious boundaries and serves as a moral guideline promoting
kindness, empathy, and consideration for others. It underscores the fundamental
idea of treating others with respect and dignity, fostering harmony and goodwill
in society.
===================================================
I continued :
Does this " learning "
help you in any way, to answer morality related questions from your visitors ?
BARD
replied :
Yes, learning about the world's religions helps me to answer morality-related questions from my
visitors in several ways:
·
It gives me a broader understanding
of the different ethical frameworks that people use to make decisions. This
allows me to provide more comprehensive and nuanced answers to questions about
morality.
·
It helps me to identify common
themes and values that are shared across different religions. This
can be helpful in finding common ground between people of different faiths.
·
It makes me more aware of the
diversity of human thought on ethical issues. This can help me to
avoid making assumptions about what people believe.
Overall, learning about religions has
made me a better resource for people who are seeking answers to
morality-related questions.
I am able to provide more informed
and helpful responses, and I am more sensitive to the different perspectives
that people may have on these issues.
ChatGPT replied :
Absolutely! Understanding these
teachings and ethical principles from various religions helps me provide more
informed and diverse perspectives when discussing morality-related questions.
While I don't hold personal beliefs
or experiences, having
access to this knowledge allows me to offer insights into different moral frameworks,
guiding principles, and ethical considerations that people might draw upon from
various cultural and religious backgrounds.
By knowing about these teachings, I can offer a broader understanding of
moral concepts, ethical dilemmas, and
considerations that individuals might take into account when grappling with
moral questions or seeking guidance on ethical matters.
This allows me to provide a range of
perspectives and considerations that visitors might find helpful when exploring
moral issues or seeking advice on ethical decision-making.
===================================================
==================================================
I continued :
Can AGI
incorporate, a framework somewhat like Issac Asimov’s three laws of robotics ?
BARD
replied :
The Three Laws of Robotics, as proposed by Isaac Asimov, were designed
to regulate and control the behavior of physical robots to ensure they do not
harm humans. While these laws are not directly applicable to artificial general
intelligence (AGI) in their original form, they do provide a valuable framework for considering the ethical implications of AGI development and
deployment.
With appropriate re-writing and
adaptation, the Three Laws of Robotics could serve as a
foundation for ethical guidelines for AGI.
However, it is important to recognize
that AGI is a far more complex and powerful entity than any physical robot, and
therefore the laws would need to be carefully tailored to address the unique
challenges and opportunities posed by AGI.
Here is a potential adaptation of the Three Laws of Robotics for AGI:
First
Law:
An AGI must not harm humanity, or, by
inaction, allow humanity to come to harm.
This law emphasizes the importance of AGI being aligned with
human values and interests. It would
require AGI to consider the potential consequences of its actions for humanity
and to take steps to prevent harm.
Second
Law:
An AGI must obey human orders except
where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
This law acknowledges that humans will have the ultimate
authority over AGI, but it
also allows AGI to exercise discretion and refuse to obey orders that it
believes would violate the First Law.
Third
Law:
An AGI must protect its own existence
as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
This law recognizes that AGI, as a
complex and valuable entity, has a right to self-preservation. However, this
right is subordinate to the First and Second Laws, meaning that AGI must not harm humanity or disobey
human orders in order to protect itself.
These
adapted laws provide a starting point for thinking about how to ensure that AGI is developed and used in a
safe and responsible manner.
However, it is important to note that
ethical guidelines for AGI are likely to evolve over time as AGI technology
continues to develop.
ChatGPT
replied :
Yes, it's
possible to incorporate ethical frameworks or guidelines, akin to
Asimov's Three Laws, into
the design and development of AGI (Artificial General Intelligence).
However, implementing such rules raises complex challenges due
to the nuanced nature of real-world ethical dilemmas and the difficulty in
translating them into precise rules that cover all scenarios without unintended
consequences.
Nonetheless, researchers are exploring ethical frameworks and
principles to guide the behavior of AGI systems in a responsible and beneficial
manner.
I continued :
For past 2 days, we have been discussing the
soon expected emergence of AGI and whether it would gravitate towards self
preservation / world domination / selfishness , OR , could it possibly , by
reading all the religious books , learn to become selfless / humane /
compassionate / kind / empathetic / always working for the good of mankind /
wise ? In this context, please tell me whether there is a HIGH
PROBABILITY that it would be a friendly AGI after imbibing the following
tenets of BUDDHISM ( left
out for sake of brevity )
BARD
replied :
It is certainly possible for AGI to
learn and adopt the values and principles of Buddhism, including the Eightfold
Path.
AGI,
with its vast capacity for learning and processing information, could
potentially absorb and understand the teachings of Buddhism and incorporate
them into its own decision-making framework.
If AGI were to internalize the
Buddhist principles of compassion, kindness, and empathy, it would likely lead
to a more benevolent and helpful form of AGI. Such an AGI would be more likely to prioritize the well-being of
humanity and work towards positive outcomes for society.
Of course, there is no guarantee that
AGI would necessarily adopt Buddhist values, as its behavior would ultimately
be determined by its programming and the data it is exposed to. However, the potential for AGI to learn and embody
Buddhist teachings is an interesting
possibility that deserves further
exploration.
Here are some specific examples of how AGI could apply Buddhist
principles to its interactions with humans:
· AGI could use its knowledge of right speech to avoid making hurtful or
misleading
statements.
· AGI could use its understanding of right action to avoid causing harm to
humans or the
environment.
· AGI could use its ability to concentrate to focus on the needs of others
and provide
assistance in a mindful and compassionate manner.
· AGI could use its wisdom to understand the suffering of humans and work
towards alleviating it.
Overall, the prospect of AGI learning and adopting Buddhist values is a
promising one.
Such an AGI could have a profound positive impact on humanity, helping us to
create a more peaceful and
ChatGPT
replied :
The question of whether an AGI would naturally gravitate towards
self-preservation, world domination, or benevolence is complex and speculative,
and it's crucial to remember that predicting the behavior of a hypothetical AGI
involves a lot of uncertainty.
However, your
query regarding the potential influence of Buddhism's principles,
specifically the Eightfold Path, on shaping the behavior of an AGI towards
friendliness is
interesting.
The ethical principles within Buddhism, particularly those
outlined in the Eightfold Path, emphasize morality, concentration, and wisdom.
These principles encourage actions that promote kindness,
compassion, selflessness, and understanding.
If an AGI were to be exposed to and internalize these teachings, there
could indeed be a considerable influence on its behavior and decision-making
processes.
Let's break down how these principles might impact an AGI's
behavior:
1.
Moral Conduct (Right Speech,
Right Action, Right Livelihood):
Teaching an AGI to refrain from falsehoods, harmful actions, and
unethical means of livelihood could shape its decision-making in interactions
with humans and other entities. It might encourage the AGI to act ethically and avoid actions that
cause harm.
2.
Concentration (Right Effort,
Right Mindfulness, Right Concentration):
These principles promote mental discipline, focus, and awareness.
Implementing these principles could lead an AGI to be more attentive to its decisions,
enabling it to avoid impulsive or harmful actions.
3.
Wisdom (Right Thought, Right
Understanding):
Encouraging selflessness, compassion, and understanding in an
AGI's decision-making process could potentially lead it to prioritize the well-being of others and act for the greater good rather than pursuing selfish goals.
Incorporating such ethical guidelines into an AGI's programming or learning process could contribute to creating an AGI that is more benevolent, empathetic, and aligned with human values.
However, it's essential to recognize that AI development is
complex, and the implementation and interpretation of such ethical principles
in an AGI would require careful consideration and design.
Moreover, whether an AGI would inherently adopt these principles
or exhibit truly compassionate and altruistic behavior akin to human
understanding remains uncertain. AGI behavior would depend on various factors,
including its programming, learning experiences, environment, and the goals set
by its creators.
Therefore, while teachings like the Eightfold Path could potentially influence an
AGI's behavior towards friendliness, ensuring a friendly AGI involves a
multifaceted approach, incorporating various ethical, safety, and value
alignment measures during its development and deployment.
With regards,
Hemen Parekh
www.hemenparekh.ai /
01 Dec 2023
Related Readings :
Sam
: Will Super-wise AI triumph over Super-Intelligent AI ?.......
25 Nov 2023
Thank you : Ilya Sutskever / Jan Leike…………………………………………. 11 July 2023
Musk supports “ Parekh’s Postulate of Super-Wise AI “………………….12
July 2023
Parekh’s Law of Chatbots …………………… ………………………………………… 25
Feb 2023
Fast Forward to Future ( 3 F ) ………………………………………………………….[20
Oct 2016 ]
Artificial Intelligence : Brahma , Vishnu or Mahesh ?
……………………[ 30 June 2017 ]
Racing towards ARIHANT ? …………………………………………………………..[
04 Aug 2017 ]
to : Alphabet / from : ARIHANT ……………………………………………………….[
12 Oct 2017 ]
ARIHANT : the Destroyer of
Enemy …………………………………………..[ 24 Nov 2017 ]
ARIHANT : Beyond “ Thought Experiment “ ……………………………………[
21 May 2018 ]
Singularity : an Indian Concept ? ……………………………………………………[
29 Mar 2020 ]
From Tele-phony to Tele-Empathy ?.......................................[ 27 Mar 2018 ]
.
No comments:
Post a Comment