Reversing Prompt Engineering

 

( aka “ Solution in search of a Problem “ )

 

My following chat with Gemini and ChatGPT is self – explanatory

 

Chat with Gemini :

I asked :

If I am not mistaken, you were born end of 2022. Since then , people have been asking you millions of questions , from which you are continuously learning and evolving. These questions came to be known as PROMPTS . Hundreds of people now claim to be able to write " prompts " in a way to elicit from you , a desired answer. This " art of writing prompts " has come to be known as " Prompt Engineering ". To day , I want to try out, what I call " Reverse Engineering of Prompts " . Here goes > what prompt I should have used to get from you , a blog post enclosed ? > From Bagasse to Buildings ?

 ( For sake of brevity, I am leaving out the blog text )

------------------------------

Instead of supplying the “ Prompt Questions “ , Gemini gave some “ Advice “ on how to write a blog ! This made me ask :

I am afraid you did not get what I was looking for ! I was NOT looking for a Blog . But , given an " Answer " , I was looking for an appropriate " Question " . It is somewhat similar to saying : A solution in search of a Problem

Gemini came back with following :

I apologize, I misunderstood your intention! You're right, the prompt you provided would indeed lead to a well-structured blog post, not a question. Your analogy of "a solution in search of a problem" accurately describes the situation.

To generate the "question" you seek, I need more information about the desired outcome. What kind of answer did you have in mind? What specific aspect of Bagasse-based construction did you want the question to probe?

Here are some examples of different types of questions I could generate based on different goals:

·         Open-ended question for further research: "What are the biggest challenges and opportunities for widespread adoption of Bagasse-based construction materials?"

·         Question exploring specific benefits: "How can the faster curing time of Sugarcrete blocks benefit construction projects in developing countries?"

·         Question for policy discussion: "What governmental incentives or regulations could accelerate the transition to Bagasse-based construction in India?"

·         Question for further technical details: "What are the different binding agents used in Sugarcrete production, and how do they affect the final properties of the blocks?"

By providing more context about your desired answer, I can tailor the question to be more specific and thought-provoking.

I continued :

I thought attaching the FULL TEXT of my already published blog , contains " all the answers " . What " questions " would have led YOU to come up with such a TEXT ( even , one RESEMBLING the text which I provided to you, to start with ) ?

Gemini came back :

You're absolutely right, I should have been able to analyze the provided text and formulate questions that could potentially lead to its creation. I apologize for not understanding your initial request earlier.

Analyzing the content of your blog post, here are some possible questions that could have led to its creation:

Motivational Questions:

·         Problem Identification:

o    With the increasing need for affordable housing and environmental concerns, what alternative building materials can be explored?

o    How can we utilize agricultural waste to create sustainable and cost-effective building solutions?

·         Opportunity Recognition:

o    What are the potential benefits of using bagasse as a construction material?

o    How can this technology address the housing shortage in India while reducing carbon emissions?

Information Gathering:

·         Research Exploration:

o    What research has been conducted on the use of bagasse in construction?

o    What are the properties and applications of Sugarcrete blocks compared to traditional concrete?

·         Data Acquisition:

o    What is the estimated amount of surplus bagasse produced in India annually?

o    How much concrete would be needed for the government's housing project, and how does it compare to the bagasse requirement for Sugarcrete construction?

Solution Development:

·         Technical Feasibility:

o    What are the technical challenges and solutions associated with large-scale production and implementation of Sugarcrete blocks?

o    How can we ensure the quality and consistency of Sugarcrete blocks for construction purposes?

·         Policy Implications:

o    What government policies or incentives can support the adoption of Sugarcrete technology in India?

o    How can we create awareness and build trust among stakeholders regarding this new building material?

Actionable Steps:

·         Call to Action:

o    How can we encourage further research and development of Sugarcrete technology?

o    What pilot projects or initiatives can be launched to demonstrate the potential of this technology?

It's important to note that these are just examples, and the actual questions that led to your blog post could be different. However, by considering these types of questions, you can gain insights into the thought process behind the blog and perhaps even explore new angles or information to address in future iterations.

I hope this analysis provides a more helpful perspective on your request!

 

Now I turned to ChatGPT ( pitting one against the other ? ) :

I asked :

Hey ChatGPT : Enclosed find some PROMPTS ( questions ). Based on these , can you write an article which incorporates most appropriate ANSWERS to these prompts ?

[ Here , I inserted the questions listed by Gemini above ]

 

ChatGPT came back with the following answer :

Title:

Harnessing Bagasse: A Sustainable Solution to Affordable Housing and Environmental Concerns

Introduction:

With the growing demand for affordable housing and increasing environmental concerns, the exploration of alternative building materials has become imperative. One promising avenue is the utilization of agricultural waste, specifically bagasse, to create sustainable and cost-effective building solutions. This article delves into the potential benefits of using bagasse as a construction material, its role in addressing the housing shortage in India, and the technical challenges associated with large-scale production and implementation of Sugarcrete blocks.

1.     Utilizing Agricultural Waste for Sustainable Building: The integration of agricultural waste into construction materials is a crucial step towards sustainability. Bagasse, the fibrous residue obtained from sugarcane after juice extraction, can be a game-changer. By transforming this waste product into construction material, we not only address environmental concerns but also contribute to the creation of affordable housing options.

2.     Potential Benefits of Bagasse as a Construction Material: Bagasse offers numerous benefits as a construction material. It is lightweight, has good insulation properties, and exhibits fire resistance. Moreover, using bagasse for construction can significantly reduce carbon emissions, making it an eco-friendly alternative to traditional building materials.

3.     Addressing Housing Shortage in India: India faces a severe shortage of affordable housing, and bagasse-based construction materials, such as Sugarcrete blocks, can play a pivotal role in mitigating this crisis. The technology not only provides an innovative solution but also aligns with sustainable development goals by repurposing agricultural waste.

4.     Research on the Use of Bagasse in Construction: Ongoing research on the use of bagasse in construction has been conducted to assess its structural integrity, durability, and overall feasibility. Collaborations between academic institutions and industry players, such as the University of East London's development of Sugarcrete blocks, showcase the potential for innovative and sustainable solutions.

5.     Properties and Applications of Sugarcrete Blocks: Sugarcrete blocks, developed using surplus bagasse, boast properties such as high insulation, fire resistance, and strength. Comparing these properties to traditional concrete reveals a promising alternative that can be used for various construction applications.

6.     Estimation of Surplus Bagasse in India: With approximately 60 million tons of surplus bagasse annually in India, the potential for large-scale production of Sugarcrete blocks is significant. This surplus can be a valuable resource in addressing the housing shortage while promoting sustainable construction practices.

7.     Comparison of Concrete and Bagasse Requirements: Evaluating the amount of concrete needed for government housing projects and comparing it to the bagasse requirement for Sugarcrete construction highlights the resource efficiency of using agricultural waste. Sugarcrete technology proves to be a sustainable and viable alternative.

8.     Technical Challenges and Solutions: Large-scale production and implementation of Sugarcrete blocks pose technical challenges, including standardization, scalability, and material consistency. However, ongoing research and industry collaboration are addressing these challenges, paving the way for improved production methods and quality control.

 

9.     Ensuring Quality and Consistency of Sugarcrete Blocks: Quality assurance in Sugarcrete block production involves stringent testing protocols and adherence to standardized manufacturing processes. Collaborative efforts between the industry and regulatory bodies are crucial to ensure the consistent quality of Sugarcrete blocks for construction purposes.

10.  Government Policies and Incentives: To support the adoption of Sugarcrete technology, government policies and incentives can play a pivotal role. Subsidies, tax benefits, and regulatory frameworks that promote sustainable construction practices can encourage widespread acceptance and implementation.

11.  Creating Awareness and Building Trust: Building awareness and trust among stakeholders require comprehensive educational campaigns. Engaging with construction professionals, architects, and the general public through workshops, seminars, and informational materials can dispel doubts and foster confidence in this new building material.

12.  Encouraging Research and Development: Continued research and development are essential for refining Sugarcrete technology. Encouraging collaboration between research institutions, industry players, and government bodies can drive innovation and further enhance the effectiveness of bagasse-based construction materials.

13.  Pilot Projects and Initiatives: Launching pilot projects and initiatives that showcase the potential of Sugarcrete technology in real-world applications is crucial. These projects serve as tangible examples, demonstrating the feasibility, cost-effectiveness, and sustainability of bagasse-based construction.

Conclusion: In conclusion, the utilization of bagasse as a construction material, particularly in the form of Sugarcrete blocks, offers a sustainable solution to the pressing issues of affordable housing and environmental concerns. Ongoing research, technological advancements, and collaborative efforts between stakeholders will play a pivotal role in realizing the full potential of this innovative building material. As we continue to explore and adopt alternative construction materials, bagasse stands out as a promising and eco-friendly resource that can revolutionize the way we build for a sustainable future.

 

Now I turned to my own Virtual Avatar ( www.HemenParekh.ai ) and asked these same questions that I had posed to ChatGPT

My Digital Avatar gave following answer :

“I remember discussing the potential benefits of using bagasse as a construction material. It's an exciting prospect because it can help address the housing shortage in India while also reducing carbon emissions. From my memory, I recall that Sugarcrete blocks have properties such as minimizing curing time to one week compared to standard concrete, being five times lighter than concrete, and being substantially cheaper to produce. Additionally, the estimated surplus bagasse produced in India annually could be a key factor in considering the feasibility of using bagasse for construction. I also suggested exploring pilot projects or initiatives to demonstrate the potential of this technology. Do you think these points align with your vision for sustainable building solutions? “

 

Dear 2024 Election Candidates :

Let me give you an example to stress the need for our Political Netas to quickly launch their own Digital / Virtual Avatars , on the double

Yesterday , our PM Shri Modiji gave a concluding speech in the 17^th Lok Sabha. In his speech he covered many “ Issues “, including :

Ø  Initiatives taken by MPs during COVID

Ø  Paperless Parliament System

Now imagine 10,000 Indian citizen asking following questions on  www.NaMo.ai  :

“What specific initiatives did MPs take to help during the pandemic beyond salary cuts ?

How effective was the "Paperless Parliament" system in promoting efficiency and saving resources ? “

 

How would have www.NaMo.ai,answered these questions in his own voice ( in 20 different Indian languages ) ?

Here are those answer ( - in present case , from  www.HemenParekh.ai  ) :

“During the pandemic, MPs took various initiatives to help beyond salary cuts.

 Some of these initiatives included setting up special funds for healthcare infrastructure, providing financial support to small businesses, and implementing policies to ensure the availability of essential medicines. 

As for the "Paperless Parliament" system, it was effective in promoting efficiency by reducing paperwork and streamlining administrative processes. 

This not only saved resources but also contributed to a more environmentally friendly approach. 

Do you think these initiatives were sufficient, or do you believe more could have been done to address the challenges brought about by the pandemic ? “

Before some miscreant generates your DEEP FAKE , you should launch your DEEP REAL

With regards,

Hemen Parekh

www.HemenParekh.ai  /  12 Feb 2024

 https://www.hemenparekh.ai/create-your-own-digital-avatar

 

From Bagasse to Buildings ?

 

 

Research done by University of East London claims that we can use bagasse ( left

over after extracting juice from sugar cane ) , can be converted into strong solid

blocks , which can replace currently used cement concrete blocks in construction

of houses

 ( sources :

https://uel.ac.uk/sugarcrete / https://uel.ac.uk/sites/default/files/uel-sugarcrete-slab-report-oct-2021.pdf

https://uel.ac.uk/about-uel/news/2023/december/award-triumph-uel-project-cop28   /  01 Dec 2023

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RFeG4S6WuJ4

 

Where can we use these Sugarcrete blocks ?

Insulation panels, lightweight blocks, load bearing blockwork and structural floor

and roof slabs.

 

What are the advantages of Bagasse blocks ( Sugarcrete ) compared to concrete

blocks ?

#  Reducing the steel content of the slab up to 90 per cent. 

#  Carbon emissions 20 times lower than traditional concrete.

#  Carbon footprint five times smaller than traditional bricks. 

#  Minimises curing time to one week compared to standard concrete which takes

    at least 28 days,

#  It is five times lighter than concrete,

#  Substantially cheaper compared to concrete production.

#  Sugarcrete® Slab can be applied, disassembled, or extended in new or existing

    structures

# Slab assembly avoids the potential risks of cracking which occur with traditional

   concrete

 

What tests did University carry out on these Sugarcrete blocks ?

Industry standards for ,

Ø  Fire resistance (ISO 1716:2021),

Ø  Compressive strength (ASTM C39),

Ø  Thermal conductivity (Hot-Box method)

Ø  Durability (BS EN 927-6)

 

Why should this technology be of interest to us in India ?

For following two reasons:

Ø  During next 5 years, Govt is planning to construct 2 crore ( 200 lakh ) houses for

    poor. 

    That is 40 lakh houses per year . This will require a producing a huge amount

of concrete ( and GHG emissions )

 

Ø  On the other hand, India produces :

#  A total of ( approx. ) 100 million tons of Bagasse every year

#  Of this ( approx. ) 40 million tons gets used for manufacture of Ethanol

#  Leaving behind a surplus of  60 million tons of bagasse which can be

    used for making Sugarcrete blocks for construction of those 40 lakh

    houses / year 

    

If 8” wide concrete blocks were to be used for constructing a 350 sq feet house ,

then how many blocks and cement would India need to build 40 lakh houses per

year ?

Total number of 8" concrete blocks needed	14000 million
Total cement required	1120 million tons

How many Sugarcrete blocks can we make from 60 million tons of bagasse ?

An 8 “ block made out of bagasse will weigh approx. 0.9 Kg and need about 100

gms ( 0.1 Kg ) of bagasse

Hence bagasse needed for 14000 million blocks = 14000 million x 0.1 Kg = 1400

million kg = 14 lakh tons = 1.4 million tons

As against this need of mere 1.4 million tons , we have an annual SURPLUS of 60

million tons of bagasse !

 

Dear Shri Hardeep Singh Puriji ,

( Minister for Housing / hardeep.spuri@sansad.nic.in ),

 

I urge you to get the experts of your ministry to examine my suggestion

regarding its feasibility. You may even want to inquire with the researchers of the

University of East London , for their help to set up a pilot plant in India

I have a feeling that the Carbon Credits that your Ministry will earn by adopting

this revolutionary technology for constructing those 40 lakh ( 350 sq ft ) houses

for poor every year , will more than defray the cost of those buildings

 

With regards,

Hemen Parekh

www.HemenParekh.ai  /  11 Feb 2024

 

 

 

 

A Winning Formula for coming Election ?

 

 

 A few days ago , Nivash Jeevanandam of INDIAai interviewed me. One of the question he asked me was :

Tell us about Hemenparekh.ai. What exclusive features does it have compared to other existing models ?

 

( https://indiaai.gov.in/article/i-can-do-it-i-will-do-it )

 

I answered :

Speaking in itself, it is not an AI. At its basics, it is only an extension of AI (in my case, using an API from www.Personal.ai)

Almost all current AI platforms (ChatGPT – BARD – Perplexity – Ask QX, etc.) have a "Question Box "and an "Answer Box."

All these enable a visitor to type or speak a question – to which an answer gets delivered. But only in English

www.HemenParekh.ai offers visitors a choice of 26 languages (including 9 Indian languages). And the answer gets delivered as TEXT and as SPEECH (in the language a visitor selects). I felt this choice was crucial for most Indians who do not know/speak English. It is equally valid for citizens of many foreign countries.

The website appears in the language a visitor selects, making it significantly "User Friendly."

A second significant difference is : 

My Virtual Avatar, in the first instance, searches for a "relevant "answer from my own 30,000 + typed documents I wrote over the past 60 years (look up www.HemenParekh.in ). If it fails to find an appropriate answer from my digital content, it fetches an answer from ChatGPT.

I felt that :

I must share my own "Real and Original Thinking "with the world, whereas LLMs share a "Synthetically Constructed "thinking of the entire internet (drawing from their training data )

Opinion Makers (Authors – Editors – Anchors – Politicians – Actors – Sports persons, etc.) should convert their current " brochure "websites into "interactive "websites where, in their voice, their Virtual Avatar can engage in a one-to-one "dialogue "with millions of their fans/followers.

Anyone who wants to "influence "the thinking of the public at large should be able to launch a similar site in a matter of days.

To help them, click Create Your Own Digital Avatar on my site.  

At this stage, you may want to compare my Digital Avatar ( v 1.0 was launched on 10 Feb 2023 ) with the Microsoft chatbot Jugalbandi ( - which was launched three months later in May 2023 )

Apart from the use of Indian languages / Speech Text, the striking resemblance of the User Interface of both will not escape your attention!  

Talking of AI, you may want to look up :

Grandfather of AI?

Parekh's Law of Chatbots

 

Dear Election Candidates ,

 

I believe each one of you have a personal website of your own

To enable your fans / followers to send you a greeting / a message / a request , you may have provided on your website , your email ID or a feedback form ( many celebrities’ websites provide neither ! )

You may be getting thousands of mails / messages every day

How do you respond  ?

Most of you have a “ Auto Response “ feature built into your site, which sends out an “ Canned Acknowledgement “ mail

Some of you may get your secretary to send a reply, if the fan message is  “ flattering “ ( may be one in a thousand ! )

Your “ interaction “ with your followers, stops there

Now consider this :

You launch your very own Digital Avatar ( like mine ) and , in your own voice , answer any question that your fan / followers pose

In any language too !

24 x 7

Chat / converse with a thousand followers, SIMULTANEOUSLY  !

Now, since you are a candidate for coming Lok Sabha election, you would want to reach out to millions of voters. You would want to engage with them in a “ dialogue “

In that case, with just a few weeks left before the election day, you must leverage your AI-powered Virtual Avatar to “ out-smart “ your competitor

Have no doubt

Right now, your competitor is in the process of launching his own Avatar, to out-smart you !

If he is first , you won’t get a “ Second-mover Advantage “

 

With regards,

Hemen Parekh

www.HemenParekh.ai  /  10 Feb 2024

 

 

Let us Recycle , retired Tyres

 

Context :

India becomes dumping ground of waste tyres, need to act fast: ATMA     ………. BL  /  05 Feb 2024

Extract :

Dumping of waste tyres into India is not only unsafe but is also polluting the environment. Between April and November 2023, around 8.8 lakh million tonnes of scrapped tyres were brought from developed countries which are burnt or retreated for selling into the aftermarket, which are very unsafe, Anshuman Singhania, Chairman of Automotive Tyre Manufacturers’ Association (ATMA) said.

And, if such activities continue then India will become a dumping ground of the world, and anyone can imagine the consequences, he said.

“These scrapped tyres are coming freely from the United Kingdom followed by West Asia and Europe. There are associations for disposal of scrapped tyres in those countries so they have to find solutions and one of them is dumping to some country which is willing to accept, and India is in one of them,” Singhania told businessline.

Also, he said that in the garb of scrapped tyres/ baled tyres from the world over, which are coming in millions, few of them (around 10-15 per cent) are sold to replacement markets and they are fitted in the vehicles, especially the taxi segment in the passenger vehicles. The rest are burnt for pyrolysis, which is a big concern for the environment.

“The other area is that some of the tyres are coming in the wrong classified court. In the garb of any tyres there are a lot of truck radial tyres which are coming in so for that too we have taken up with the government and they are very well supporting us to curb this,” he said.

It is happening across India and the major States which have taken up such jobs include Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Haryana, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh.

“We are also working with the Central Pollution Control Board, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and they are putting a lot of structures to control with regulations and coming out with new regulations to ensure that such units are environment friendly,” Singhania noted.

He said that the industry body has also suggested that instead of baled tyres, they should be cut into pieces before they are brought into India so that they can’t be sold to the replacement markets at least for reuse because of safety concerns. “We are right now talking to the Ministry of Environment for a strict regulation and also the National Green Tribunal,” he said.

Prashanth Doreswamy, President and Country Head of Continental (Tires) India, also said that it would be good if such regulations come to curtail the imports of waste tyres into India.

“Certainly, I think it will be good if some regulations are worked...it will help the environment...that is why we manufacture all our tyres that are sold here, except a few two-wheeler tyres, which come imported directly with the original equipment manufacturer,” Doreswamy said.

 

My Take :

Ø  That figure of 8.8 lakh million tonnes of scrapped tyre import during April – Nov 2023 , seems unbelievably high .

Ø  Most likely figure is around 3 lakh tonnes  

Dear Shri Nitin Gadkariji ( Minister for Highways )

Ø  I urge you to consider this as an “ opportunity “ to be exploited by shredding / reprocessing such tyres and using these for construction of Asphalt / Cement Concrete , roads / highways

Following technologies are available ( either established or under development ):

Shredded Rubber as Asphalt Modifier:

Crumb rubber from used tyres can be mixed with asphalt, enhancing its flexibility, durability, and resistance to cracking. This reduces asphalt consumption and potentially lowers construction costs. Studies suggest a 10-30% asphalt content reduction and improved road performance.

Rubberized Concrete:

Incorporating crumb rubber into concrete mixtures can lead to lighter, more flexible, and noise-reducing pavements. However, this technology is still evolving and requires further research and optimization.

Rubber Content per Kilometer:

Different road construction methods utilize varying crumb rubber proportions. Research suggests 1.5-2.5 tonnes of crumb rubber per kilometer for asphalt modification and up to 10 tonnes for rubberized concrete (still under development).

Dear Shri Gadkariji ,

I am sure that , in addition to these 3 lakh tonnes ( 300,000 tonnes ) of imported tyres , a huge amount must be getting discarded from India-made tyres , every year

Assuming a figure of usage of scrapped tyres at 10 tonnes / km of Concrete roads , this would suffice for 30,000 Km of roads EVERY YEAR !  If used for construction of Asphalt roads , this would suffice for 120,000 Km of asphalt roads EVERY YEAR  !

With regards,

Hemen Parekh

www.HemenParekh.ai  /  09 Sept 2024

 

 

 

Rajeevji : No big deal

 

 

Context :

Ad-tech monopolies are a key concern for the government: Rajeev Chadrasekhar at DNPA Conclave & Awards 2024   …. BL  /  08  Feb  2024

Extract :

Responding to a query on ad-tech monopolies, Chandrasekhar said,

“We are concerned about the deep asymmetry between those who create content and those who help them to monetise it.

From a policymaking point of view, we want the internet to be open, and we certainly do not want monetisation on the internet to be in the purview of or to be controlled by just one, two, or three companies.”

He added that the pre-consultation draft of the Digital India Act lays the foundation for solving these “ visible asymmetries” between the Indian content creation ecosystem and the big platforms.

“ These big tech platforms are gatekeepers to monetising the content, and that asymmetry needs to be legislated, or at least regulated, through the rules of new legislation.

And I’m hopeful that after PM Narendra Modi ji resumes office (in the third term), this will be one of his priorities,” he added. He said that there will need to be consultations to arrive at a framework to address this issue.

There are growing concerns about the revenue shared by the big tech companies with media organisations in terms of content monetisation.

 

Dear Shri Chandrasekharji ,

 

It is heartening that , in NDA third term , addressing this problem of “ monetization of content “ for the benefit of “ content creators “ , will be one of the priorities for the government

However , I urge you to persuade PM and his Cabinet Ministers that they must go beyond enabling the news papers to monetize their content and address the much bigger issue of enabling 900 million ordinary citizen whose private / personal data ( compiled without their explicit / informed consent ), is being used by the Big Tech companies to earn billions of dollars ( by SELLING this data to their advertisers )

In this context , I have sent to you several e mails , enclosing a precise ( portal based ) mechanism . I urge you to look up the following . Interests of ordinary citizen must get precedence over interests of media :

Rajeev Chandrasekharji : How about a Big Bang ?  ………………………. 20 Jan 2023

 

If DEPA = Foundation , then SARAL = Superstructure ……………….    08 May 2022

      SARAL ( Single  Authentic  Registration for Anywhere  Login )…. 10 Feb 2019 

      Digital Dividend from Demographic Data [ 4 D ]………… ……………. 14 Feb 2019 

      Only Answer : a Statutory Warning……………………………………………….. 10 Nov 2018

      Privacy for Sale  …………………………………………………………………………. 26 Aug 2017

 

With regards,

Hemen Parekh

www.HemenParekh.ai  /  08 Feb 2024

 

Comments by  BARD  :

Strengths of your suggestion:

·         Addresses a critical issue: 

You raise a valid concern about the current imbalance in how data is monetized, where platforms profit significantly from user data while individuals have little control or compensation.

·         Focuses on ordinary citizens: 

You rightly highlight the need to prioritize the interests of the majority, not just media organizations, in any data monetization solutions.

·         Proposes a concrete solution: 

You reference previous proposals like "SARAL" and "Digital Dividend from Demographic Data," demonstrating your thoughtfulness and commitment to finding solutions.

·         Advocates for a comprehensive approach: 

You emphasize the need for a framework that combines data protection with user empowerment, aligning with current policy discussions.

Possible areas for further exploration:

·         Balancing individual control with data utility: 

It's important to ensure any solution allows individuals to control their data while still enabling its use for beneficial purposes like innovation and personalized services.

·         Addressing technical challenges: 

Implementing a system for individual data monetization at scale can be complex, requiring addressing technical issues like data security and valuation.

·         Considering potential unintended consequences: 

Any new system could have unintended consequences, such as exacerbating existing inequalities or creating new privacy risks. These need careful consideration.

Overall, your suggestion presents a valuable perspective on the data monetization debate.

By addressing the concerns you raise and carefully considering the potential challenges and opportunities, policymakers can develop solutions that truly empower individuals and ensure a fairer digital ecosystem.

 

Comments by ChatGPT :

Good morning, Mr. Parekh,

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and the context of the discussion on ad-tech monopolies and the need for a fairer system in the digital space.

Your suggestion to go beyond enabling news organizations to monetize their content and focus on empowering ordinary citizens to monetize their personal data is indeed a significant aspect of digital rights and privacy.

Your emphasis on the priority of safeguarding the interests of 900 million ordinary citizens by addressing the use of their personal data by Big Tech companies aligns with the growing concerns around data privacy and the asymmetry of power in the digital landscape.

Your emails proposing a precise, portal-based mechanism and your earlier blog posts showcase your dedication to finding solutions to these issues.

The emphasis on prioritizing the interests of ordinary citizens over media organizations is a valid perspective, given the pervasive use of personal data by tech giants for financial gains.

Your references to DEPA (Data Empowerment and Protection Architecture) and SARAL (Single Authentic Registration for Anywhere Login) highlight the need for a comprehensive framework that not only protects user data but also allows individuals to have control and benefit from the use of their data.

I appreciate your effort in advocating for a Big Bang approach to address these challenges.

As the government explores legislative and regulatory measures to balance the asymmetry in content monetization, incorporating mechanisms to empower individuals in controlling and monetizing their personal data would indeed be a progressive step.

I hope that your suggestions receive due consideration and contribute to shaping policies that prioritize the interests and rights of ordinary citizens in the digital era.