Hi Friends,

Even as I launch this today ( my 80th Birthday ), I realize that there is yet so much to say and do. There is just no time to look back, no time to wonder,"Will anyone read these pages?"

With regards,
Hemen Parekh
27 June 2013

Now as I approach my 90th birthday ( 27 June 2023 ) , I invite you to visit my Digital Avatar ( www.hemenparekh.ai ) – and continue chatting with me , even when I am no more here physically

Translate

Friday, 20 November 2026





--------------------------------------------------------

Modi Is Right. Here's How to Make It Stick: A Framework for Demand-Led Growth through Strategic Wage Increases

By Hemen Parekh | 20 November 2026


The Headline Everyone Missed

Last week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Labour Minister Smt. Anuradha Thakur took an unconventional step: they told industrialists to raise wages.

Not gently suggested. Not hinted at in a speech. Told them directly: employees are underpaid. The country needs to boost purchasing power. Without demand, growth stalls.

The economic press treated it as a one-day story.

It is actually a confession of policy failure — and an opportunity for course correction.

For a decade, we've cut corporate taxes. We've offered tax incentives. We've liberalized FDI rules. We've simplified compliance. And yet, the wage bill of Indian workers—as a share of GDP—has flatlined. Meanwhile, the richest 1% has pulled further ahead.

Modi's statement is saying what should have been obvious all along: Lower taxes without rising wages is not a growth strategy. It's a wealth-concentration mechanism.

Here's what needs to happen next.


The Demand Problem Is Real

The latest World Bank data confirms it. India's GDP growth remains resilient, but real earnings growth has stalled.

A 2.6% poverty rate and 134 million new jobs between 2017–2023 sound good. But dig deeper:

  • New jobs are mostly low-productivity work. A street vendor or unregistered construction worker earning ₹8,000/month is counted as "employed," but doesn't have the purchasing power to demand consumer goods, durable services, or high-value products.
  • Youth unemployment rose from 14.6% to 15.9% (FY26 to FY27), even as older cohorts found work.
  • Real wages for entry-level workers have barely budged, while inflation has eaten into purchasing power.

This creates a "demand ceiling." Manufacturing capacity sits idle. Retailers discount aggressively. E-commerce platforms can't achieve profitability. The MSME sector, which employs 120 million people, is squeezed between suppliers demanding payment and consumers unable to pay premium prices.

The bottleneck is not supply. It's demand.


Why Modi's Wage Call Matters

When the Prime Minister tells industrialists to raise wages, he is implicitly rejecting a decade's worth of "low-cost competitiveness" orthodoxy.

That orthodoxy said:

  • Lower wages = lower production costs = cheaper exports = bigger market share.
  • Keep wages flat, inflation low, and India becomes the "low-cost economy."

It didn't work.

Why? Because a low-cost economy built on stagnant wages is a poor economy. And poor economies don't generate the domestic demand needed to sustain manufacturing.

Japan proved this in reverse. As I documented recently, Japan's wages flatlined from 1990 to 2023—averaging just $46,792 to $46,792 (a rise of $98 over 33 years). But Japan maintained full employment, robust social safety nets, and stable prices. It worked for Japan because Japan had already built a high-productivity, capital-intensive economy. Workers earned little because costs were low for everyone.

India is different. We have:

  • Underemployed labor (self-employed vendors, gig workers with zero security)
  • Weak domestic supply chains
  • Insufficient infrastructure
  • Skill gaps between job openings and job seekers

In this context, keeping wages flat doesn't create a "virtuous circle of cost reduction." It creates a vicious circle of stagnant demand → underutilized capacity → delayed hiring → more wage pressure → workers dropping out of the formal economy.

Modi's statement is a recognition of this trap.


What Workers Do When They Have Extra Money

This is where your 2016 work becomes relevant. In "What Would They Do?", I  laid out exactly what happens when workers have more purchasing power:

Middle-class workers (₹2.5–10 lakh annual income):

  • Invest in bank deposits, fixed deposits, mutual funds, life insurance
  • Increase their debt servicing capacity (credit rating rises)
  • Take larger loans for home purchases and auto financing
  • Invest in children's education
  • Reduce dependence on male child for old-age support (a profound social shift)

Neo-middle-class workers (₹5–15 lakh annual income):

  • Buy items of daily necessity: food, clothing, basic durables
  • Transition from cash to formal banking (reduces black money)
  • Use mobile wallets, credit cards, and digital payments
  • Become eligible for microloans and peer-to-peer lending

Result:

  • Bank deposits soar → banks can lend to startups and MSMEs
  • Consumer durables demand rises → manufacturing hires more workers
  • Formal banking penetration increases → GST collection rises
  • Housing finance demand expands → construction boom → jobs in MSME subcontracting

This is not a theory. This is arithmetic.

If 50 million formal workers get a 10% wage raise, that's roughly ₹25,000–50,000 extra per year per worker. Multiply by 50 million: ₹1.25–2.5 lakh crore in additional household purchasing power.

GST at 5–18% on that consumption: ₹6,250–45,000 crore back to government coffers. The tax revenue loss from NOT cutting corporate taxes (or cutting them less aggressively) is offset by GST on worker spending.


The Missing Piece: Linking Tax Cuts to Employment

Here's where my  "Inverse Corporate Tax Regime" becomes critical.

Since 2014, India has repeatedly cut corporate tax rates—from 30% to 25%, then to 15% for new manufacturing. But companies have not proportionally increased hiring. Why? Because:

  1. A flat tax cut is an incentive to any behavior — automation, outsourcing, shareholder buybacks, or hiring. Firms choose whichever maximizes profits, not jobs.
  2. Without a constraint, firms will automate. A ₹5 crore tax saving can either hire 10 workers at ₹50 lakh each or buy one robot that displaces 50 workers.
  3. The government got the incentive structure backwards. Instead of "lower tax broadly," it should be "lower tax specifically for each additional worker hired."

Here's the framework I have proposed repeatedly since 2014:

Company Employment Size Corporate Tax Rate Rationale
Up to 100 persons 30% Startups, tiny firms; higher rate but volume incentive
101–500 persons 25% Small-to-medium enterprises
501–1,000 persons 20% Growing mid-market firms
1,001–5,000 persons 15% Large employers
5,001–10,000 persons 10% Mega employers
Above 10,000 persons 5% World-scale job creators

Additional tax breaks for youth employment:

  • Average employee age < 25 years: additional 2% tax credit
  • Average employee age < 30 years: additional 1% tax credit

Why this works:

  1. It aligns incentive with goal. A company wants to hire 500 more workers? It goes from 25% tax to 20% tax. The tax savings help fund the wage increase. It's not arbitrary—it scales with job creation.
  2. It discourages automation at the margin. Not outright (robots are still useful), but it makes hiring a viable alternative to replacing workers.
  3. It's transparent. A firm can calculate: "If I hire 1,000 more people, my tax rate drops from 20% to 15%, saving ₹X. Can I pay ₹Y more per worker with that saving?" The answer is often yes.
  4. It's revenue-positive for government. The tax rate is lower, but the tax base (more employed workers, more consumption, more GST) grows faster than the rate decline. Net result: government collects more total tax.

The government actually moved toward this with the Employment Linked Incentive (ELI) Scheme in 2024. But ELI is a temporary incentive (2 years), capped at ₹3,000/month, and applies only to new hires. The Inverse Tax Regime would be permanent, structural, and apply to total employment.


The Virtuous Circle (And How to Activate It)

Connect the pieces:

Step 1: Link corporate tax to employment

  • Firms hiring more workers pay lower tax rates
  • Tax savings help fund wage increases

Step 2: Wage increases boost household purchasing power

  • Workers spend on housing, durables, education, health
  • Formal banking deposits rise
  • GST collections rise

Step 3: Higher demand drives manufacturing

  • Consumer durables factories operate at full capacity
  • MSME subcontracting increases (65 million MSMEs employ 120 million people)
  • Real estate, logistics, and services expand

Step 4: More hiring in response to demand

  • Companies create new jobs to meet higher demand
  • Lower tax rate kicks in automatically for each additional worker
  • Upward pressure on wages (from competition for talent) is absorbed by company tax savings

Step 5: Loop closes

  • More workers earning more → more consumption → more GST → government revenue increases despite lower tax rates
  • Employment rises faster than wages, so unit labor cost stays reasonable (inflation controlled)
  • Exports remain competitive and domestic demand is strong

This is not theoretical. Japan achieved this in the 1960s–1980s before wages froze. Germany has achieved it through its "social market" model—high wages, strong unions, mandatory worker representation on boards, and competitive global exports.

India can achieve it, but only if the government makes employment itself the tax-relief metric, not just company size or profitability.


What Modi and Anuradha Thakur Should Do Next

The statement was important. The framework needs to follow:

1. Replace Broad Corporate Tax Cuts with Employment-Linked Tax Cuts

Don't cut corporate tax from 20% to 18% for everyone. Instead:

  • Base rate: 20% (for reference employment level)
  • For each 10% increase in employee count: 1% rate reduction
  • Cap: 5% for mega-employers (above 10,000 people)

2. Extend ELI to a Permanent "Wage Incentive" Mechanism

The current ELI is temporary and limited. Make it permanent:

  • Government subsidizes 25% of wage increases above inflation for companies that maintain or grow employment
  • Subsidy is funded from tax revenue gains (higher GST, more income tax from workers)

3. Tie Wage Growth Targets to Public Procurement

Companies that pay median wages in their sector get:

  • Priority in government tenders
  • Higher PSU procurement quotas
  • Faster regulatory clearances

Companies that pay bottom-decile wages get:

  • Mandatory third-party audit of wage structures
  • Restricted access to government contracts
  • Public disclosure of wage gaps

4. Measure and Publish Employment Intensity

As I have proposed, government should publish:

  • Employment density by industry and region
  • Wage-to-productivity ratios (revealing automation trends)
  • Job creation vs. automation rates (sector-wise)
  • Youth unemployment by district

This creates pressure on underperforming companies and regions.

5. Update Labour Laws to Match

Firms can only take advantage of employment tax breaks if they:

  • Maintain transparent payroll records
  • File quarterly employment data with ITR
  • Comply with minimum wage laws
  • Provide portable social security (health, retirement, disability)

This protects workers and prevents companies from gaming the system by hiring on paper only.


Why This Matters Now

We are at a decision point.

Option A (Status Quo):

  • Keep corporate taxes low (across the board)
  • Hope companies invest in India
  • Accept that most new jobs are low-wage, informal
  • Watch domestic demand stagnate
  • Export manufacturing to remain competitive
  • Growth flattens as demand ceiling is hit

Option B (Employment-Linked Taxation):

  • Lower taxes specifically for companies that hire and pay fair wages
  • Use tax savings to co-fund wage increases
  • Activate household purchasing power
  • Build domestic manufacturing capacity
  • Create a virtuous cycle of investment, hiring, and consumption
  • Achieve both export competitiveness and domestic-driven growth

Modi's recent statement suggests the government recognizes we're hitting the demand ceiling. The question is: will the policy framework follow?


A Call to Action

The framework exists. It's been in my blogs since 2014. The Employment Linked Incentive was a step toward it in 2024. But it needs to go further and become structural, not temporary.


To Shri Modi and Smt. Anuradha Thakur: 

Make the wage-employment link permanent in tax policy.


To Indian industry: 

Stop resisting higher wages as a cost. Recognize it as a demand lever that expands your market.


To workers and unions: 

Stop arguing for wage increases in a vacuum. Link them to company employment targets—if the company hires more, wages rise proportionally.


To economists and media: 

Stop treating wage stagnation as inevitable. It's a policy choice. We can choose differently.


What do you think? 


Can India build a growth model where higher wages and job creation reinforce each other? 

Or are we wedded to the low-cost economy model indefinitely? 

Let me know in the comments.


Sources & References:


With regards,


Hemen Parekh


www.HemenParekh.ai  /  www.Iam-Immortal.ai  /  www.YourContentCreator.in 


20 November 2026

No comments:

Post a Comment