The Dutch Watchdog Is Right — But Two Years Late
The Dutch Privacy Authority's Warning on Smart Glasses Needed to Come Earlier. Here's What Must Happen Next.
Date: 19 November 2026
Published by: Hemen Parekh
The Alert That Should Have Come in 2024
On 18 November 2026, the Dutch Privacy Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, AP) issued a stark warning: smart glasses with integrated cameras pose an unprecedented surveillance risk in public spaces. Users must disclose that they're wearing recording devices. Manufacturers must build in safeguards. Governments must set rules.
The AP is correct on all counts.
The problem: they're two years late.
I wrote in July 2024, in my blog "Deepfakes Fears as AI Gets Photos Talking," that the moment generative AI learned to animate still photographs, the door opened to synthetic deepfakes of anyone, anywhere. Smart glasses merely completed the pipeline: capture high-resolution biometric data (face, gait, iris pattern) in real time, feed it to a generative model, and you've weaponized identity itself.
The AP's warning is a necessary correction. But it also exposes the deeper failure: governments and regulators move too slowly for the pace of AI.
What the AP Got Right
The AP's statement rests on three pillars:
- Ambient Data Collection Without Consent: A person wearing smart glasses with a camera cannot realistically obtain consent from every person they encounter. You cannot ask the entire street for permission to wear glasses.
- Algorithmic Intent Is Not Human Intent: The glasses themselves are "smart"—running on-device object detection, face recognition, activity logging. Even if the wearer has benign intentions, the glass's AI layer is constantly analyzing and storing data about strangers.
- Public Spaces Deserve Public Protection: Unlike your home or office, public streets have no "reasonable expectation of privacy"—but they should have a reasonable expectation that mass surveillance infrastructure is transparently signaled and regulated.
All three are sound. I've argued the same points myself.
But the AP stopped short. Here's what they should have said next:
The AP's Recommendation Falls Short
The AP recommended that smart glasses users:
- Inform people they're wearing recording devices
- Tell bystanders how their data will be used
- Explain that it may be shared or analyzed
This is "consumer disclosure"—the regulatory equivalent of a warning label on cigarettes.
It will not work.
Here's why:
First: Disclosure Without Design Change Shifts Burden to the Wrong Party
The AP is asking the user to manage the technology's risks. But the user is not the problem—the technology is. A person wearing smart glasses shouldn't have to give a speech to every stranger they pass. The burden should be on the manufacturer to make the glasses themselves signal their operating state.
Second: Verbal Disclosure Is Unenforceable
How will you prove that someone wearing smart glasses told you they were recording? There's no audit trail. If a dispute arises later ("You didn't tell me you were filming"), it's his word against yours. Regulators cannot build compliance around pinky promises.
Third: Disclosure Doesn't Stop Misuse
A person could disclose that their glasses are recording. That person could also be a stalker, a corporate spy, or someone with a hidden agenda. Knowing someone is recording doesn't protect you if they're recording for harmful purposes.
What the AP Should Have Mandated (And What I'm Proposing)
Here's what real governance looks like:
1. Mandatory Physical Signaling
The smartglasses manufacturer must build in a hardware-level indicator that:
- Is always visible when the camera is active (not a software toggle that can be disabled)
- Cannot be disabled or hidden (physically embedded in the frame, not covered by clothing or angles)
- Is universally recognizable (e.g., a flashing amber light, a colored lens border, an audible tone)
- Signals algorithmic intent, not just recording (different colors for "recording only" vs. "recording + local AI processing" vs. "recording + cloud transmission")
This is what I proposed in my October 2026 blog "DPDP Framework for an AI-Driven Future": governments should legislate a "Color Code for Surveillance" similar to how we mandate brake lights and turn signals on vehicles.
A person in a public space should be able to look at another person and know, instantly, whether they're being analyzed by algorithms. This restores agency.
2. Manufacturer Liability for Misuse
Right now, if someone uses smart glasses to stalk you, the manufacturer bears no responsibility. I want to reverse that.
Manufacturers should be held strictly liable for:
- Failure to include audible/visual indicators
- Failure to disable cloud transmission features in public spaces (local-only processing)
- Failure to implement automatic data deletion for frames captured in areas with high foot traffic
- Failure to authenticate and log every query to on-device facial recognition (so stalking attempts leave a trail)
This creates incentive alignment: manufacturers will design glasses to be harder to misuse, not easier.
3. Regulatory Inspection and Certification
Before smart glasses can be sold in a jurisdiction, they should require:
- A product safety certificate issued by an independent regulator (similar to CE marking in Europe)
- Proof that physical signaling cannot be disabled (independent testers must verify that removing the light, disabling the audio alert, or covering the colored indicator breaks the device's functionality)
- Transparent logging of all data retention (how long does the device keep biometric data? Where is it stored? Who can access it?)
The AP should inspect glasses before they're sold, not investigate misuse after the fact.
4. User Consent Infrastructure
Here's a radical idea: smart glasses should come with a hardware "consent button" that:
- Activates recording only when pressed (Bluetooth broadcasts a one-time token to nearby phones, saying "I'm about to record—opt out now if you want")
- Provides a timeout (after 30 seconds of inactivity, recording stops unless actively reactivated)
- Logs every activation and recipient consent (you can prove who you informed and when)
This isn't perfect. But it's better than relying on people to remember to tell strangers they're being recorded.
Why the AP Stopped Short (And Why That Matters)
The Dutch Privacy Authority is a respected regulator. They were not being careless. They stopped short because:
- Manufacturers lobby hard against design mandates (they claim it's "not technically feasible" or "too expensive")
- Regulators lack enforcement capacity (the AP has no power to seize devices, only to issue fines)
- EU law is fragmented (what the Netherlands requires, Germany might not; what works in Brussels might not work in Copenhagen)
- International competition pressure (if the EU mandates strict rules, manufacturers move production to Asia or the US)
These are real constraints. But they're not insurmountable. What's needed is political will.
India has shown this will before. When NITI Aayog proposed Aadhaar, critics said it was impossible—too many languages, too many people, too little infrastructure. India built it anyway. When the Ministry of Electronics & IT pushed for India Stack integration, skeptics said the financial sector wouldn't cooperate. It did.
India's Ministry of Electronics & IT and Ministry of Communications could commission a "Smart Glasses Safety Certification Framework" and make it the global standard. If India certifies smart glasses this way, manufacturers will have to meet the standard everywhere.
A Timeline: Where We Are and Where We Need to Be
2024 (Where We Were):
- Smart glasses become mainstream
- Deepfake technology reaches consumer-grade sophistication
- Generative AI learns to animate still photos with high fidelity
- No regulatory response
2026 (Where We Are Now):
- Dutch Privacy Authority issues warning (disclosure-based)
- Governments still debating
- Manufacturers still selling unregulated glasses
- Deepfake porn and stalking incidents rising
2027-2028 (Where We Should Be):
- India proposes "Smart Glasses Safety Framework"
- Independent certification of physical signaling
- Mandatory consent buttons and logging
- Manufacturer liability for misuse
2029-2030 (Where We Could Be):
- Global standard for smart glasses safety
- Hardware-enforced signaling (no way to hide or disable)
- Stalking and harassment incidents drop significantly
- Trust in public spaces restored
A Question for Regulators
The AP ended its statement by calling for a "broad stakeholder discussion."
I have a question for them: How many more years are we willing to let this discussion continue while manufacturers sell unregulated devices and people get stalked, harassed, and deepfaked?
The technology exists to solve this problem today. Colored lens borders, audible alerts, mandatory consent buttons, biometric logging—none of this requires breakthrough innovation. It requires regulation.
The Dutch Privacy Authority has drawn a line in the sand. The question is whether other regulators will follow, or whether we'll continue pretending that voluntary disclosure will protect people from mass surveillance.
I know where I stand. The AP is right. Now make them mandatory.
With regards,
Hemen Parekh
www.HemenParekh.ai
19 November 2026
No comments:
Post a Comment