Hi Friends,

Even as I launch this today ( my 80th Birthday ), I realize that there is yet so much to say and do. There is just no time to look back, no time to wonder,"Will anyone read these pages?"

With regards,
Hemen Parekh
27 June 2013

Now as I approach my 90th birthday ( 27 June 2023 ) , I invite you to visit my Digital Avatar ( www.hemenparekh.ai ) – and continue chatting with me , even when I am no more here physically

Translate

Tuesday, 25 August 2026

NEET : Not so Neat !

 




I asked META about possibility of conducting NEET exam from homes of

candidates ( much like various online exams being conducted by MICROSOFT .

Here is what META said :


===================================================

Microsoft's certification program is one of the oldest in IT.


1. How long has it been going on?


1992: 

Microsoft launched the MCP - Microsoft Certified Professional program. That was

 the start.1


1990s - 2000s: 

They introduced the famous tracks like MCSE (Microsoft Certified Systems

 Engineer / later Solutions Expert) and MCSD, MCSA.


 If you mean "Microsoft Certified Software Engineer" - that is usually MCSE /

 MCSD.


2018: 

Microsoft retired the old MCSA/MCSE/MCSD naming and moved to role-based

 certifications - Azure Fundamentals, Azure Developer Associate, Azure Solutions

 Architect Expert etc.


2020-2021: 

All remaining old MCSE/MCSA/MCSD exams were officially retired on Jan 31, 


2021. 

Now the program is all Azure, Microsoft 365, Power Platform etc.

 en.wikipedia.orgSo the program has been going for 33+ years.


2. Can you take it from home?


Yes.

Since late 2014, Microsoft partnered with Pearson VUE to offer Online Proctored

 (OnVUE) exams from home or office.Before that it was only at physical test

 centers (Pearson VUE and Prometric).


During COVID in 2020, online from home became the default. Today almost all

 Microsoft exams (except a few lab-based) can be taken from home. 

You pay the same price as test center. campustechnology.com


What you need at home:

- a clean, private room, desk, webcam, microphone, stable internet, and you have

 to do a 360-degree room scan with webcam before starting.

 campustechnology.com


3. Is there cheating / security problem?

Yes, this has been a constant battle for Microsoft, like for all IT vendors.


How they secure online exams:

Secure browser that locks your PC

Live proctor monitors you by video + audio the whole time, you are recordedFacial

 comparison to your IDIf proctor suspects cheating, they terminate exam and

 report to Microsoft. 


Exam can be invalidated and candidate can be decertified and banned

 learn.microsoft.com


What problems have been reported:


Braindump sites

Microsoft is one of the biggest targets. In one analysis 328 sites were selling

 Microsoft exam dumps.


Data forensics: 

Microsoft uses pattern analysis - unusual response times, aberrant answers - to

 detect people who used braindumps. They say the system has 1-in-a-trillion false

 positive rate and they ban based on that data alone.


Online proctoring tricks: 


People try to use second device, someone off-camera, etc. Microsoft says they

 review video where cheating is suspected and "We're pretty good at detecting

 cheating, so we don't recommend it—we decertify cheaters, remove their

 certifications, and ban them".


 networkworld.comlearn.microsoft.comlearn.microsoft.comSo:


 Yes, you CAN take it from home now, it has been possible for ∼11 years, but it is

 heavily monitored, and cheating is taken very seriously with lifetime bans.

================================================

I asked :

" Are there large number of young Indian talking such tests from their homes ?

 How many took in 2025 ?


Could this system work for NEET exam with 25 lakh candidates?


====================================================

META replied :

" Yes, India is now Microsoft's largest certification market in the world — and most of those are now from home.


1. Are young Indians taking Microsoft tests from home? How many in 2025?


Yes, in very large numbers.

Microsoft does not publish an exact country-wise exam count, but they gave scale indicators:


Dec 2022: 

Microsoft announced a program to train and certify 1 lakh+ Indian developers in 1

 month under Future Ready Champions of Code.


Feb 2024: 

Microsoft pledged to train 2 million Indians in AI by 2025 under ADVANTA(I)GE

 India.

May 2025: 

Microsoft said they already trained 2.4 million in India, 74% from Tier 2 and Tier 3

 cities, 65% women and pledged 5 lakh more by 2026. financialexpress.comThat

 2.4 million is training - but certifications are attached to it. 


Industry estimates from Pearson VUE India: 

India does 600k-800k Microsoft certification attempts per year now, and since

 2020, 70-80% are Online Proctored (OnVUE) from home because test centers

 can't handle volume. 


For young developers 22-32 years in Hyderabad, Bangalore, Pune, NCR - home

 test is now the norm.


So for 2025, realistically 5-7 lakh Microsoft certification exams were taken from

 homes in India.


2. Could this system work for NEET with 25 lakh candidates?


Short answer: 

Not directly from homes, but the technology behind it can be used at secure

centers.


Why Microsoft from home works:

Test-taker pool is spread over 365 days. 

100 people at a time globally.

One live proctor can watch 6-8 candidates. 

If internet fails, exam can be rescheduled.


Why NEET from homes on same day will NOT work:


Scale on one day: 


NEET is 23-25 lakh on ONE day, same 3 hours

You would need 3-4 lakh live proctors and AI servers watching simultaneously.

 Pearson VUE globally proctors a few lakh per YEAR, not per day.


Digital divide


Microsoft test-takers have good PCs, 20+ Mbps internet, private room. 

Many NEET aspirants are from rural areas without that. 


Government itself admitted online NEET is "safer but highly complex" and needs

 massive infrastructure expansion.


Cheating incentive 1000x higher: 


Microsoft exam is for a job skill


NEET is for a medical seat - incentive to cheat is crores. 


At home, methods like second person whispering off-camera, remote desktop

software are much harder to stop at this stakes.


Normalization problem: 


To handle 25 lakh with computers, you cannot have 25 lakh computers. 


Govt plan leaked for 2027 is 20 sessions spread across 10 days to accommodate

 everyone. 


Then you need 20 different question papers and normalization - which brings its

 own fairness lawsuits. 


What IS happening:


The government has accepted that OMR paper + truck + wax seal system is

 broken. 


The official plan now:


NEET moving from pen-paper OMR to Computer-Based Test (CBT) from 2027, but

NOT from home - at NTA-controlled secure centers, like JEE and CUET already do.


Multi-layered frisking, police escort of servers, AI CCTV, facial recognition, Aadhaar

fingerprint auth.


Experts say CBT "can help reduce paper transportation leaks, printing press

 vulnerabilities, mass photocopy circulation" but needs protection against hacking,

server attacks, remote access. 



My take: 


Microsoft model proves that secure online proctoring technology (AI eye-tracking,

keystroke dynamics, forensic analysis) is mature.


It should be adopted for NEET, but only at official centers, not at home.


From-home for 25 lakh high-stakes candidates = logistical nightmare and new

cheating industry.



No comments:

Post a Comment